Second Dates

By bonneville on December 28, 2021

Listen to Second Dates every Monday, Wednesday and Friday at 7:30am and 9:30am, and every Tuesday and Thursday at 6:30am and 8:30am!

Want to submit a Second Date? Click HERE!

 

Tracy and Rob (Feel For The Third Wheel) – One of our listeners got to that crucial post-date moment where a kiss SHOULD happen, but she hesitated… what caused her to blow her big chance? Your Second Date will explain next!

 

Samantha and Ian (Match, Mix and Repeat) – The woman in today’s Second Date says the other patrons of the restaurant were giving her weird looks all night, all because of one thing she was compulsively doing. Did it cause the guy she was with to ditch her?

 

Aaron and Laurie (Mexican Food Mystery) – One of our listeners contacted us asking for a Second Date because he woke up with a receipt for SIXTY tacos the morning after.

 

Eric and Carrie (Unidentified Family Opportunity) – One of our listeners met his date’s family on NIGHT ONE, and we’re gonna hear what happened to make it all go wrong in your Second Date!

 

Julie and Dennis (Build-A-Burn) – After their date ended with a romantic kiss, Dennis vanished off of social media completely. Now Julie is calling us for some assistance in a Second Date!

 

Valerie and Dave (Wrong Number Is Oh So Right) – One of our listeners made a harmless mistake on her first date, but the guy she saw is adamant that she actually ruined his life. Dramatic much?

 

Andrew and Sandra (Don’t Go Chasing Wedding Vows) – Things got weird in today’s Second Date but we’re glad Sandra didn’t bail on Andrew during their date… at least not right away.

 

Rick and Bella (Take a Picture Of My Date) – One of our listeners wants help getting hundreds of dollars back from someone he barely knows, all without ruining his chance at another rendezvous.


 

Josh & Erica (It Takes A Village) – An instant turn-off we’ve never heard of before happened in today’s Second Date… and it happened while walking past a bank. Find out what it was in the podcast!

 

Maryell and Pete (Adulting Out of Control) – One of our listeners took a risk and invited a guy back to her place on a first date. Ever since then, he’s been avoiding her. Did she scare him off or is there another explanation??

 

 

Nick & Britney (PETrifying Dinner Party) – We’ve had countless moments on this show that have left us speechless, but NOTHING tops what happened in today’s Second Date!

 

Julian and Abby (Wax On Date Off) – The guy in today’s Second Date was so smooth with his pickup line was so smooth that it impressed all of us in studio. He made the first move but can we help him finish the job?

 

James and Tara (Bad Boy or Just Boy) – What would you do if a guy says “I have a surprise for you… and it’s in my coat pocket?” It happened in today’s Second Date and we’ll let you know what happened with Mr. Pocket Surprise in the podcast!

 

Morgan and Kent (Brunette Has A Nice Ring To It) – One of our listeners received one of the lamest pickup lines of all time… and went along with it! It ended her up here for a brand new Second Date podcast!

 

 

Logan and Ellie (Plane In The Neck) – We might have had one the most awkward “jump to conclusion” moments we’ve ever had on this show and we’re just shocked we didn’t screw it up for the guy. Hear it in your new Second Date podcast!

 

Gail and Jonathan (Senior Moment Slip Up) – One of our listeners admits she broke more than FIVE unwritten rules of dating, but she says she had a good reason too! Hear what happened in a brand new Second Date podcast!

 

Mark and Chloe (Factory Fail) – One of our listeners says he planned a surprise experience for a first date and it went off the rails almost immediately! You’re gonna hear what it was in a brand new Second Date.

 

Andrew and Tabitha (Bats on the Beach) – The guy in today’s Second Date said he tangled tongues at a very awkward time right in the middle of his date, and he DIDN’T initiate it. Why isn’t he getting a call back?

 

Justin and Kasey (The Boring Test) – One of our listeners claims he’s developed a plan to determine is someone is relationship-worthy on the very first date. But does his system sound too good to be true?

 

Taylor and Murphy (Paint the Baby Room) – The woman on the phone with us for today’s Second Date said her night included someone going into LABOR, and it actually led to a fun night anyway?

 

Ricky and Kelly (Double the Dobermans) – One of our listeners got a phone number in one of the most creative ways we’ve ever heard. Will this revolutionize how we meet strangers forever? Or ruin in-person dating permanently?

 

Mark and Ava (Strife with Surprises) – The guy on the phone for today’s Second Date actually put a lot of thought, effort and energy into his big dates idea, but he’s still getting blown off days later. We’re gonna put on our hero capes and try to save him!


 

William and Rachelle (Coffee & Canines) – If we could give any advice to the average dater today it would be: BE PREPARED FOR ANYTHING IF YOU COME TO US FOR HELP. You’ll hear what we mean in the podcast!

 

Roofer & Chloe (Return of Roofer) – We have a return caller who left an unforgettable impression on us last time. Now, “ROOFER” is back and making his glorious return to the show!

 

Maggie and Darren (Locked In The Park) – The couple in today’s Second Date were trapped inside a public park at night and were unable to leave. Now that they’ve finally gotten out they’re gonna tell us the story of their date!

 

Daniel and Rebecca (Father Permission) – If you only listen to one Second Date all summer make it this one! Not a single one of us in studio saw what was coming and you can hear for yourself in the podcast!


 

Nicole and Nathan (Google Gaffe) – A woman emailed us and said she has a big secret about the guy she went out with and begged us not to tell him! Not only is it awkward and embarrassing, but it’s possible he might have known all along.

 

Wayne and Isabella (Happy Shamaversary) – One of our listeners tried to go the “funny” route for a first date activity and it ended up stinking worse than Brooke’s microwaved lunches. You’ll hear what happened in a brand new Second Date podcast!

 

Todd & Monica (Todd The Bod) – The guy in today’s Second Date gave himself a saucy nickname that you’ll never forget. You’ll hear it and hear how turned on Brooke was by it, in your new Second Date podcast!

 

Eddie & Melanie (Finding Nemo Losing Date) – The guy in today’s Second Date is wondering if the surprise he prepared on the first date was TOO MUCH, and now wants our help to reconnect with the woman he might have scared away!

 

Maddie and Derek (Drop-Off Daddy) – We found out the person on the phone with us for a Second Date was kind-of internet famous… and when it came out during the call it left everyone on the show completely speechless.

 

Mike and April (To Cheat Or Not To Cheat) – One of our listeners met an incredible woman 5 years ago, and only now is he finally ready to reach out. Why did he wait so long and did he miss his chance? Find out next!

 

Mary Louise and Dominic (Dude Where’s Her Car?) – One of our listeners felt comfortable letting her date do something that some couples wait months or years to do… She put a lot of trust in him and unfortunately that backfired on her.

 

Keith and Ellie (Hot Tub Boob Job) – The guy on the phone for today’s Second Date insisted that he send us a shirtless picture of him to help explain what went wrong on his date. It seemed weird but it ended up being really important!

 

 

Julia and Brett (The Case of the Mysterious Limp) – We’re going to do something a little different in today’s Second Date: actually TRY. A suspicious thing happened at the end of our listener’s date and she wants us to investigate what really happened for her.

 

Abraham and Vicki (Toilet Paper Prank) – Right from the jump, Jeffrey made a huge blunder in today’s Second Date… He asked our producers not to air it, which means of course we did anyway!

 

Noah and Holly (Whack Beach Wedding) – You have to take risks if you want to find true love! One of our listeners did exactly that when he crashed a strangers wedding! Hear what other dangerous moves he made in an all new Second Date Podcast!

 

Melanie and Jarred (Crystal Clear Aura) – The woman on the phone for today’s Second Date had a date at a café where she pulled something out of her purse and rubbed it on the guy’s leg… It sounds strange, but it’ll make sense once you find out what it is!

 

Charles and Melanie (Models and Manchester) – A professional model says she recently started listening to our show, but is she open to love with one of our listeners?

 

Rob and Tiffany (Not-So Spontaneous) – Today’s Second Date played out like an epic game of clue. Someone pulled one of the sneakiest and most backstabbing moves in show history.

 

Kara and Clinton (Bookstore Friend Zone) – Getting friend zoned is awkward and confusing, and one of our listeners is worried the guy she’s VERY interested just wants to be friends. Can we help them become maybe a little more?

 

Jack and Michelle (Super Rich Sucks) – The couple in today’s Second Date went on one of the most elaborate dates we’ve ever heard of!

 

Daymond and Millie (Male Model Mishap Karma) – The guy in today’s Second Date shouldn’t need our help… he’s a male model. But his first date went from really great to really awkward and now he’s wondering if he made a mistake?

 

Brian and Alana (Ghosting Karma) – One of our listeners had his date spoiled by something he saw inside the restaurant. It was unexpected and he’s hoping his date didn’t catch on… you’ll find out what happened in your Second Date!

 

Max and Beth (Promtastrophe) – Have standards even been lower in the dating game? Today’s Second Date might restore your faith in romance, because one of our listeners went above and beyond to engineer one special night.

 

Brett and Page (Mexican Walkout) – What do you do when you can see your date getting less interested in your as the night goes on? One of our listeners had that problem and he tried everything to turn the night around. Hear what he did in your Second Date!

 

Joseph and Monica (Marvel Knockout) – The guy in today’s Second Date attempted a sweet & romantic gesture on his movie date, but it went so poorly he ended up embarrassed and apologizing. Find out what he did, and if it was a big deal breaker!

 

Jamie and Clay (Quirky Lady) – The woman in today’s Second Date will be someone we’ll be talking about for years, all because of her one bizarre dating ritual!

 

Chase and Kelly (Putt Putt Ghost) – The guy in today’s Second Date was having the worst nights of his life… before a beautiful woman stepped in and changed everything…
 

Ben and Terri (Snacks & Secrets) – The woman in today’s Second Date says it only took a singular, cheeky one-liner to get Ben interested in her. Hear what the magic words were in the podcast!

 

Derrick and Katy (Mysterious Stranger Knocks At My Door) – Everything is all fine and dandy until a mysterious woman knocks on your door and throws your entire dating life for a loop. It happened to one of our listeners and we’ve got all the juicy details in your Second Date!

 

Brett and Rachel (Hockey Fan Gets Hosed) – Something caused the woman in today’s Second Date to abandon her date during the middle of an overtime hockey game. What was she running towards…. or ESCAPING from?

 

Allen and Erica (Boat Fished) – We’ve dealt with Catfishing on this show, but today’s Second Date might be the first case of BOATfishing in recorded history!

 

Ryan and Trinity (Sneaker Boy) – A good date always requires some planning, preparation and a little luck. The guy in today’s Second Date did something unusual to set himself up for success on his date, and it must have backfired because he’s not getting a call back without our help!

 

Abraham and Brittney (Mysterious Grilled Cheese Lady) – The woman in today’s Second Date wasn’t just rejected by one guy, but two! We’re gonna tell you all about “The Mysterious Grilled Cheese Lady” in the podcast!

 

Megan and Curtis (300 is the Magic Number) – The woman on the phone with us today had a unique idea for how to initiate the first kiss on her date, but was it too bold? She thinks it might have cost her a chance with this guy, and she wants our help in your Second Date!

 

Kenny and Ellie (Cake By The Tesla) – The guy from today’s Second Date brought his dinner date back to his place, but before the magic could begin.. something tragic happened!

 

Adam and Taylor (Drop Dead Dork) – Adam from today’s call became the center of attention during a huge event and it lead to one of the most bizarre Second Dates we’ve ever had!

 

Matthew and Julia (Discount Dining) – Sometimes one man’s idea is another man’s mistake. The guy on today’s Second Date has a fool-proof plan for getting cheap food and immaculate service, and it’s actually disgusting.

 

Connor and Renee (You Look Familiar) – The date one of our listeners had with a woman might be the biggest Twilight Zone experience we’ve ever had on this show!

 

Christina and Greg (Gambling Baseball Coach) – The guy we called in today’s Second Date offered up a “dealbreaker” that we had honestly never heard before in our lives. Hear it for yourself in the podcast!

 

Ashley and Brian (Lions & Tigers & Capybaras, Oh My!) – Not only was the guy in today’s Second Date humiliated on his night out, but it was at the hands of a 9-year old!

 

Alexandra and Scott (Pre-Engagement Ring) – We’ve seen a lot of red flags on our show over the years, but none was bigger or redder than what one woman surprised her date with before they even go to know each other!

 

Dillon and Gia (Delivery Knockout) – The guy in today’s Second Date was working as a delivery driver when he had a one in a million interaction with a woman at her front door. Now he’s desperate to get back in touch with her, and he wants our help!

 

Chris and Kayla (Surprise Party Shocker) – One of our listeners wandered into an unlocked front door before his date started and what he saw on the other side threw his entire night for a loop!

 

Rudy and Alison (Two Girls One Auction) – People love having choices. One of our listeners was out the other night and had the choice between two women who were BOTH interested in him. He made his choice… but now she’s not calling him back.

 

Jeanine and Seth (Cat Catfish) – The woman on the phone met a man on a dating site for cat lovers… And not only did she enjoy the night…But her cat approved too! So why isn’t he calling her back?

 

Nate and Meg (Dance Machine) – One of our listeners tried everything in the book to try and meet a cute girl he saw at a wedding reception, and you’re not gonna believe the sneaky move he pulled to make it happen.

 

Brandon and Jessica (Train wreck) – One of our listeners was ditched by his date almost immediately BUT he took a huge chance that ultimately paid off big!

 

Eddie and Jessica (Firefighter Lips) – We have a mystery to solve in today’s Second Date! Something that happened at a Fireman’s Ball had everyone in studio flummoxed, and we worked our hardest to get to the bottom of it.

 

Chris and Ellie (Penguins Are Sexy) – Most of the time, a tiny fib won’t cause a lot of damage to a relationship. But the lie one of our listeners told on a date came back to bite him. You’ll definitely want to hear what he said in your Second Date!

 

Dan and Jodi (Christmas Freak) – The guy in today’s call is pretty sure what his date saw inside his apartment might have ruined his chance at love… but he has a totally reasonable and non-creepy explanation for it… At least… he thinks so…

 

Chris and Avery (Two Faced Bus Driver) – One of our listeners had a great date, but the future of their relationship could hinge on one questionable choice he made 5 years before they even met…

 

Ryan and Lena (Containers, Coffee & Lies, OH MY!) – What happens when a real estate agent and an audio book narrator walk into an open house? The start of today’s Second Date!

 

Phil and Wendy (Busting A Catfish) – A crazy secret was revealed on today’s Second Date call between Phil and Wendy that not even WE saw coming!

 

Gabe and Noelle (Muppet Dinner) – Is it weird if a guy shows up to your date with two mysterious duffle bags? It happened to one of our listeners and she told us what weird things he was keeping in the bags in your Second Date Podcast!

 

Mary-Anne and David (Ew, David) – A potential future celebrity reached out, asking for our help in the love department. We’ll find out who they are… and what happened during their night out, in your Second Date!

 

Meghan and Kurt (Bathroom Burrito Disaster) – One of our listeners says the guy she went out with did the BARE MINIMUM, yet she’s still eager to get a Second Date with him! Have standards ever been lower?

 

 

Kyle and Abby (Guinness What In The World Record) – The guy in today’s Second Date attempted to become world-renowned for feet stuff. But, not only did he fail that venture, his date left him hanging as well.

 

Matt and Kelsie (MattMan Returns) – Today’s Second Date is an epic comeback opportunity for a man who’s been on our show before. He went by “Mat-Man” and today we’re going to be his trusty sidekicks!

 

Lisa and Drew (Rough Family Game Night) – The woman on today’s Second Date invited her guy over for a Family Game Night and things got a LOT more physical than he ever anticipated…


 

Gaelin and Stephanie (C’est La Spit) – Two diners sit down at a table, but 3 meals arrive. Is a mysterious stranger in their midst? Or is it just a brand new Second Date?

 

Sydney and Kurt (The Long Game) – The woman in today’s Second Date was completely floored once she ended up back at a guy’s place. There was no question she wants to see him again. But the real question is why doesn’t he want to see her?

 

James and Vicki (Smells Like Tween Spirit) – One of our listeners claims he was having a great date with a beautiful woman… but it was ruined by a roving group of 13-year-olds…

 

Rich and Sarah (Trust Fall TikTok) – The listener who needed our help with a Second Date shared a juicy detail from their first meetup that had us all floored but made us promise to not bring it up when we called his date. We’re always up for a challenge though!


 

Greg and Katie (Uptight Greg) – One of our listeners thinks he might have accidentally ruined his entire date because of what he did in a movie theater! It’s not illegal but its not a good look either…

 

Thomas and Cecelia (Trial By Separation) – The guy in today’s Second Date has been off the market for a decade and after his first date back in the game he’s getting left on read.

 

Shawn and Kat (Fast Food Limo) – The guy in today’s Second Date took one classic date idea and flipped it on its head and it made all of us in studio jealous when we heard it. Who is this beloved mystery man?

 

Tyler and Rachel (Elevator People) – Nothing bonds two people like being stuck in an elevator for hours. It happened to the couple in today’s Second Date and they’re on the line now to tell us about all the ups and downs!

 

Forrest and Chrissy (Slept Like A Baby) – Ditching your date after first meeting is bad. But one of our listeners swears he has a good reason for why he did exactly that… in your Second Date!

 

Spencer and Robin (It’s No Picnic) – One of our listeners forgot one IMPORTANT thing and it ruined his entire picnic date. After that awkwardness he’s calling us for some help grabbing him a Second Date!

 

Julie and Dennis (Build-A-Burn) – After their date ended with a romantic kiss, Dennis vanished off of social media completely. Now Julie is calling us for some assistance in an all-new Second Date!

 

Kaitlyn and Chase (E-Trade Mogul) – The woman in today’s Second Date had a date with someone very rich, and arguably pretty famous, too… but now he’s not calling back. Can we get her another shot at big time love?

 

Liam and Sandy (How Dare You Say I’m Sorry) – You won’t believe how the guy in today’s Second Date managed to score a date with a Perfect 10! He got the first date, but now he needs our help trying to wrangle another…